Logan City police went to Millennial Towers Student Housing, at 657 E. 1000 North just west of Maverik Stadium, at 11:32 p.m. on 14 December 2019 after a call about several people smoking marijuana in a student flat.[1] Officers could smell marijuana and found several people smoking in a room, and a seventh person was found hiding in a nearby bedroom.[1] Police found no drugs or drug paraphernalia at the scene, but the smell gave probable cause; the people refused consent to a urine test until officers obtained a warrant, and the tests showed marijuana in their systems.[2]

All were cited and released at the scene, with none arrested.[1] Quarterback Jordan Love, wide receiver Sean Carter, running back Gerold Bright and track athlete Elani Rice were charged on Tuesday, 17 December 2019 with possession of a controlled substance, marijuana or spice, a class B misdemeanor.[3] The fourth person cited was Elani Rice, an athlete on the university’s track and field team, who was also cited for underage alcohol possession.[1] Utah State University said citations had been issued and that its student conduct and athletics procedures would be followed.[3]

All four were cited on 17 December and their arraignment was set for 30 December.[4] A lawyer for Love said initial reports were wrong to say he had been arrested, and that no marijuana or other illegal substances were recovered at the scene.[2]