An Agra court acquitted the accused in the 17-year-old case after police failed to prove the recovery.[1] Special NDPS Judge Harshvardhan acquitted Umrao alias Dabar, a resident of Rajgarh in Madhya Pradesh, giving him the benefit of doubt.[2]

According to the Tajganj police-station complaint, Sub-Inspector Dinesh Pal reported that a police team caught Umrao near Pushpanjali Phase-4 on the night of 15 December 2009.[2] Police claimed that 150 grams of charas were recovered from his possession, after which he was produced in court and sent to jail.[2] The forensic laboratory weighed the charas at 136 grams, 14 grams less than the 150 grams the police had claimed.[2]

At trial the officer gave one station-departure time in his testimony while the recovery memo recorded another, and no general-diary copy showing the police team’s departure for the spot was produced.[2] Police never made the person who supplied the scales and weights used to weigh the charas a witness.[2] Police produced no sample-seal record and no malkhana property-store register in court, so the court acquitted the accused on the contradictions and gaps in the evidence.[2]